Response to the CBS Report on Card Collecting Dying

If you missed it this morning, CBS had a small segment on the baseball card industry and how it’s “dying”. You can view the segment here if you missed it.

The segment features the creator of a card show in Parsippany, New Jersey and how it was once a playground for collectors of all ages. Now, it’s barren with the same few “middle aged white people” there every show.

First, where the hell is Parsippany, New Jersey? And why would I ever want to go there?

Next, there is more than a single reason why collectors, even younger collectors, don’t attend these card shows anymore. And the reasons aren’t cell phones, girls, and video games. One would be the creation of the internet. The internet is like a 24-hour a day card show where you can find and buy pretty much whatever you want without having to leave the comfort of your own home. That’s gotta be where all the non “middle aged white guys” are.

The only shows worth going to anymore are the ones held annually where dealers from across the country come in with their top inventory and manufacturers are in attendance. Over 4 days last year, the National Sports Collectors Convention in Chicago drew 30,000 people in attendance including several thousand children, especially on the Sunday where children get in free. And guess what, there is a lot more product there then what I saw on video in that CBS segment, better product too. How is 30,000 people going to a single show in Chicago evidence of the hobby dying?

I could go on more into price of products, greed, asking prices at these card shows, hobby shops, etc. but that is something CBS should have done before putting together a half-assed report on television.

Yes, the hobby has taken a hit with the number of collectors since the high points in the 80s and 90s, but it’s far from a dead national past time. Every hobby has it’s peak of interest and that was it’s time, but it’s still going strong today. In fact, modern card values are selling for a pretty penny. We’re seeing sales in the 10 to 20 thousands of dollars for single cards on the secondary market. Again, how is that evidence of the hobby dying?

When people stop buying vintage cards and stop buying new products to the point where there is only one manufacturer left, you can tell me the hobby is dying. But with Upper Deck, Panini, Topps, ITG, Leaf, Benchwarmer, etc. still creating and selling trading cards, you can’t convince me of something that isn’t true.

For that terrible reporting CBS, I’m going to have everyone check out this early review of “Ball Boys” on ABC. It’s basically “Pawn Stars” but with sports memorabilia. Looks…interesting, but I’m not into television like that, but maybe you’ll like it.

What are your thoughts on the CBS piece?



Tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Response to the CBS Report on Card Collecting Dying

  1. night owl says:

    Sports Illustrated did this exact same story in 1996 or 1997 (I saved the article from when I had a subscription). There is nothing in the CBS report that wasn’t in that story from 15 years ago. So they’re telling viewers absolutely nothing new.

    You’re always going to come up short if you compare everything to the early ’90s. It was the golden era. It’ll never happen again. But I still see kids looking at and buying cards every time I go to a card show. Every time.

  2. Matt Gilman says:

    I dont have any local shows or card shops, but local retail outlets like Walmart are always selling out on stuff. If the hobby was dying they wouldn’t be. And why would places like Panini keep wanting to add more Licenses and Upper deck who are in a battle to get theirs back if the hobby was dying??? Makes no sense. Yes, sometimes I do worry to be honest. If the past 18 years were for nothing and the fact that values have dipped and the amount of people I know who collect are none, but there is a huge number that do collect. And like you pointed out, internet is the new card show. And the big ones still draw thousands. CBS needs to interview some actual card experts. And not someone from a town of nowhere NJ. So to be honest, not really worried yet. We do need help to keep kids into the hobby. But card companies I am sure are creating new ways everyday to do so.

  3. Pingback: The Weekly Panini Price Index (PPI): Justin Bieber 2.0 Auto Card Fetches Huge Bucks « The Official Panini America Blog

  4. m.b. jackson says:

    the hobby of collecting cards is definitely dying. reason is card companies continue to put all the key cards in hobby packs, and they pack them so all the crooks can hand pick the key cards, especially in rack packs. if you are buying retail cards you are throwing your money away.

If You Comment, They Will Come